Margaret “Peg” Foster and Andrew Keleman Death Obituary: Unexpected Departure
The community of Susquehanna County is grappling with deep sorrow following the tragic deaths of Margaret “Peg” Foster and her husband, Andrew Keleman, in an incident authorities are investigating as a murder-suicide. The loss has left residents stunned, while also prompting reflection on Foster’s years of dedication to education and her impact on those around her.
According to the Pennsylvania State Police, troopers were called to a residence in Jackson Township on Tuesday to conduct a welfare check. What began as a routine request turned into a heartbreaking discovery, as officers found both individuals deceased inside the home they shared. Officials later indicated that preliminary findings suggest Keleman fatally shot Foster before taking his own life. Both were in their 60s.
The investigation remains ongoing, and authorities have said more details may be released as they continue to examine the circumstances surrounding the incident. In the meantime, family members have asked for privacy as they navigate an unimaginable loss.
Margaret “Peg” Foster is being remembered as a dedicated educator whose career left a meaningful mark within the Crestwood School District. She served as principal of Fairview Elementary School and was later appointed superintendent in 2015—a role that reflected her experience and commitment to education. Although her tenure as superintendent was brief following a decision by the school board to rescind her appointment, Foster remained a figure many associated with leadership and advocacy for students and staff.
After the board’s decision, she pursued legal action, filing a federal lawsuit that alleged violations of her constitutional rights. While the case was ultimately dismissed in 2017, those who knew her say it did not define her dedication or the care she brought to her profession.
Colleagues and community members continue to remember Foster for her steady presence, her work ethic, and her efforts to support both educators and families. Her contributions to the school community are being recalled with respect and gratitude during this difficult time.
The circumstances surrounding this tragedy have cast a heavy weight over the community, highlighting how complex and often unseen personal struggles can be. As Susquehanna County mourns, many are holding onto memories of Foster’s service and extending compassion to all those affected by this loss.